Home

Previous Entry | Next Entry

Car talk

  • Jun. 9th, 2008 at 11:47 AM
happy!
In just 8 days, my 2002 Honda Civic will be all paid off. In celebration of gaining $222 back every month, I'm going to give it some cosmetic repairs as well as everything a 76,000-mile car needs. Time to consult the manual.

I had had thoughts about selling it once it was paid off, but I'm thinking it would be considerably more practical to keep it for at least a few more years. After all, it's fuel-efficient, I barely have a commute (and only three days a week at that) and I don't need to be making major purchases with the economy as it is right now.

My other thought is that I don't think I'll be buying brand-new cars in the future. Whatever psychological effect I was hoping to gain from not buying "someone else's problems" in a used car was totally destroyed when my ex low-speed crashed the car a few weeks after purchase, before I had even transferred the insurance. The repair work was done in another city, was unspeakably shoddy and not guaranteed, and my car still has a slightly bent frame, according to the Honda dealership I brought it to recently. I had bought brand-new thinking that it would hang on to its value and be pretty easy to sell, but there will clearly be some sunk costs with this particular car. At least it wasn't a lemon.

I suspect that selling it, given its history, will be something of a nightmare, even though it's been nearly as reliable as you'd expect a Honda to be at its age. Other people will likely pass it over in favor of a no-accident car, except for the very stingy types who will probably expect to get it well below blue-book value.

Another reason for hanging on to it is that I can't even make up my mind about my next car. An older, used Lexus? A slightly-used hybrid? Hold out for a SmartCar? Forego cars altogether?

A reason for getting a new-to-me car is because I want to enjoy driving, which I seriously don't, except (interestingly) when I rent a car. Then, I probably only am responding to the novelty factor. I admit that I'm quite bored of my car, but I don't want that to drive (heh) a long-term purchase, because I could easily get bored of that, too.

Curious for those of you who know cars better than me-- is it ever a good idea to stick with dealership repairs for your 6-year-old car, rather than going with your convenient neighborhood repair shop? My ex Leo got me into the habit of dealership repairs but I feel like I suffer the worse stickershock there, despite the psychological effect of comfort that the mechanics there "really know Hondas" and can get parts more quickly. Then again, how hard would it BE for ANY mechanic to really know Hondas, given their popularity?

I do miss the days when I had a mechanic in the family, locally. I also had a great relationship with the mechanics at Irish Mike's in Orlando. I'm reluctant to find someone in the area, although Vladimir at that one place near my old house with [info]unseelie23 was outstanding. He could have ripped me off were he inclined, but didn't.

Comments

[info]anthologie wrote:
Jun. 9th, 2008 07:34 pm (UTC)
If you want an absolutely awesome mechanic, go to PR Motorsports in Hayward. I know it's a bit of a hike, but they are so good and so worth it. They focus on Mazdas but are extremely well-versed in Hondas and Acuras, too.

You could always sell yours and ... do you have a Car Share program in your area? In that case, go with that - they have different cars all the time. :)
[info]savorie wrote:
Jun. 9th, 2008 08:45 pm (UTC)
I know it's a bit of a hike

"Bit of a hike" is almost always a dealbreaker for me. :-) Having your car in the shop is inconvenient as it is, and I don't require *awesome*, just competent, efficient, and not-overly-expensive. I'm sure I could do fine within MV.

I'd have to see what CarShare entails, and think about how often I would utilize it.
[info]autumnflames wrote:
Jun. 9th, 2008 07:41 pm (UTC)
I recently found a mechanic in downtown Mountain View through a colleague referral who I am really happy with. I can provide the info if you're ever interested.

I am not a car person, but I thought that the main reason to take a car to the dealer was if it was still under warranty. Otherwise, for common cars I was under the impression that it didn't matter. I've never taken my Toyota to a dealership, and I don't think I've suffered for it.
[info]savorie wrote:
Jun. 9th, 2008 08:44 pm (UTC)
Yeah, the warranty thing sticks out in my mind as the most referenced reason to go with your dealership. I also got the impression, after turning it in after warranty, that the service had a faster turnaround than a tiny autoshop would tend to have.

I would be interested in your referral.
[info]autumnflames wrote:
Jun. 9th, 2008 09:07 pm (UTC)
It's called Depot Garage, and the phone number is 650-967-2808. It's at 727 W. Evelyn, but you bring your car in through the parking lot in the back. Extra bonus is that it's probably only about a thirty minute walk from your place.

They recently installed a new alternator for me - I brought in the car around 10 or 10:30, and it was ready to pick up maybe around 4. It's run by two brothers whose parents own it.
[info]agentsteel53 wrote:
Jun. 9th, 2008 07:49 pm (UTC)
I can't even make up my mind about my next car.

why think about a next car at all, then? This one works. Essentially, since you have it all paid off, you have a FREE CAR!!!!!123, so why not hang on to it until it actually becomes a liability? A Civic with 76K miles in it is about 100-150K miles away from being a liability.
[info]savorie wrote:
Jun. 9th, 2008 08:42 pm (UTC)
A big motivating factor for me is that it's a stick shift, and I'm trying to reduce strain on my wrists. Whenever I drive an automatic, I strongly notice a difference-- they don't hurt as much. So it's already a minor liability. It would be a major one if I were commuting more than the 5 miles 3x/week that I'm doing right now.

I can't see it as a FREE CAR!!! now that it's hit the 76k mark and will need some expensive maintenance pretty soon, and kinda already does.
[info]agentsteel53 wrote:
Jun. 9th, 2008 09:12 pm (UTC)
well, all cars need maintenance... it's just that a maintenance schedule is "lumpy". Instead of paying a very small amount every few hundred miles, you go for ages and then get the equivalent of ten trillion meat cleavers to the fiscal spine.

dude, car ownership sucks ;-)
[info]stormsigma wrote:
Jun. 9th, 2008 10:22 pm (UTC)
Heh, says you!!! I don't know what I'd do if I didn't have a handy way to turn rear tires into smoke, and fuel into forward acceleration at illegal speeds!
[info]agentsteel53 wrote:
Jun. 9th, 2008 10:49 pm (UTC)
those sound like perfectly excellent forms of rental car abuse to me.
[info]stormsigma wrote:
Jun. 10th, 2008 12:35 am (UTC)
At the risk of sounding arrogant, I'd have to hit one of those "Rent an exotic" places in order to find something as fast as what I've got in my driveway.

But then, I see you're in California. I'm in Orlando, Florida. This place wouldn't know a decent public transit system if it kicked the Mayor in the ass.
[info]agentsteel53 wrote:
Jun. 10th, 2008 12:43 am (UTC)
gotcha. you, then, must be a car enthusiast. What kind of car do you have?

while I do appreciate a classic car (mmm... '69 Mustang Boss 429), in a practical context I personally like for the car to stay out of my way and let me drive to the places I wish to see.

Thus, I'll rent a car for a weekend, throw 3300 miles on it, and let someone else worry about the maintenance. The two greatest words in the English language: "unlimited miles". (The three greatest words are "collision damage waiver", for the time you inevitably hit an uninsured motorist in deer form.)

I haven't done the math in several years, so this figure may have changed, but the break-even point between buying a car and renting one is somewhere between 175 and 300 miles per day. Anything above that figure and the wear-and-tear is best passed on to someone else for the daily rental price. If I walk to do my errands, take the train to work, and then when I feel the need to see the world, I drive 600-1200 miles per day... it's a no-brainer!
[info]stormsigma wrote:
Jun. 10th, 2008 12:50 am (UTC)
I most certainly am, anything that performs on four wheels with (preferably) the power getting to the ground from the rear, or all four wheels.

I currently have an '05 GTO. She's got a bit of work done, so she's putting down about 380ish at the rear wheels. It's not the fastest car ever, but I've surprised my fair share of the stuffed-shirt Vette drivers we have around here!

What you're saying about renting a car for a long road trip, I can absolutely see that as a viable alternative if you don't want to put a beating (or worse, the miles!!!) on your own car, most definitely.

As for that break-even point, it probably has a lot to do with where you live also, because as I was somewhat referring to about Orlando is that it's very spread out. Anything you want to access is almost certainly not going to be near whatever else you might want to get to. That great Cantonese place? Yeah, that's twenty six miles away down 50, in stop and go traffic from this great bookstore/video rental place and so on. Plus, around here, the only rental places I know of all rent incredibly tiny econoboxes. I've never been comfortable in those, unfortunately.
[info]agentsteel53 wrote:
Jun. 10th, 2008 01:05 am (UTC)
380 will definitely surprise people! GTOs are awesome; quite a few of the old-school ones floating around here in San Diego.

I live in a neighbourhood where the grocery store is 2 blocks away, the bank is 3, there are about thirty restaurants and bars within a ten block radius, etc... so I can do all the really critical things on foot (certainly a good idea when one has had N beers!). I just let the less critical vehicular errands (like running to Home Depot to purchase several large items) pile up and every few weeks I rent a car and bite the bullet on not averaging the break-even quantity of miles per day!

I actually prefer the econoboxes... the price of gas what it is today, a 2500 mile road trip costs an incremental pretty penny for every mile per gallon you lose when they oh-so-courteously threaten to upgrade you to a midsize car, or, heaven forbid, an SUV.
[info]savorie wrote:
Jun. 9th, 2008 08:46 pm (UTC)
In any case, if you read the post carefully you see that I am already mostly leaning toward keeping it. I don't know about doing so for another 100k, though. Maybe.
[info]stormsigma wrote:
Jun. 9th, 2008 08:51 pm (UTC)
I would say that Autumn nailed it. If your car isn't under warranty (give its age and mileage, I'm sure it isn't) then finding the nearest reliable mechanic would be the way to go.

Also, what expensive maintenance does it need? If you've kept up with the maintenance on it thus far, then about all you actually need (and "need" is stretching a bit):

- Oil change
- New fuel filter (don't let them talk you into a fuel system flush, waste of money)
- Air filter
- Cabin filter (not sure if the Civic has one)

Otherwise, you're good. Going to a standard chain mechanic shop will have them telling you you need nonsense like a tranny or radiator flush, but unless the car is running erratically, or leaking, you actually don't.

Also, when your car is paid off, you could trade up to something with an auto in it (though be aware your gas mileage will suffer. Manuals get better mileage than slushboxes). But since the car is paid off, you'll just be responsible for the difference of course, and I'm not sure how CA is but in FL if you trade in a car worth ten grand on a car that costs twelve grand, you only have to pay sales tax on the two grand difference.

Just some things to ponder.
[info]savorie wrote:
Jun. 9th, 2008 09:33 pm (UTC)
Aw darn, I was waiting for you to give me shit about owning a Civic like you used to. You really HAVE changed! :-D

As for expensive maintenance, really the biggie is straightening out the bent frame from the years-ago accident, which is going to cost $2k and (I already checked) won't be covered by insurance. Heck, I was told by the crappy Miami mechanic who did the original fix that the frame WASN'T bent. Bastards. It very much is, and metal is rubbing against metal, probably to the detriment of the parts within.

Aside from that, I'm also thinking about potential necessary belt changes and such (again, I need to look at the manual to see what's on the schedule). It also really needs a new battery (it depletes when I go on vacation longer than 3 days) or possibly to have the alternator examined.

I need new brake pads, a side mirror (old one was taken off by a tree in my driveway), a new headlight, and some very minor detail work.

Damn, you know, I HAVE been talked into a tranny/radiator flush a couple times at oil-change shops. Now I know.

in FL if you trade in a car worth ten grand on a car that costs twelve grand, you only have to pay sales tax on the two grand difference.

What the..... no way! That almost sounds too good to be true. I'll have to look this up as I've never heard of such an arrangement.
[info]stormsigma wrote:
Jun. 9th, 2008 10:20 pm (UTC)
Hmmmm...it's a tough situation, dear. On one hand, you're about done with car payments. On the other hand, you have a car that sounds like it's going to need two thousand dollars worth of frame work on top of a few other things. The decent news is that a new battery, pads, and belts aren't that expensive by themselves and can actually all be done by you, or a friend who's even marginally proficient with hand tools. A brake job is an hour long process if you know how to use a socket wrench on 99% of the cars out there.

Same with changing out the belts for that matter.

Damn, too bad you don't live here, I'd do all that for you for the price of dinner.

Being that your car is older, I'd look on Ebay for a new headlight, also. Belts, EXAMINE THEM before you let a mechanic tell you they need to be changed. As I just said, that's also an easy job with a socket wrench. Torque the tensioner pulley, slip off the old belt, slip on the new one. Every car has a diagram under the hood that shows you the correct way to thread the belt through all the pullies. ZERO guesswork.

Also. A new side mirror? Get on your yellow pages and look for a nearby junkyard. There were roughly eight hundred million Civics made all in your body style, so it's almost certain that you'll be able to get a part (and most likely in your color too) and it's a simple replacement.

The other option here is that you see what somewhere like Carmax would give you for the car, and take that two grand you would have paid on it, and put it down on another inexpensive economy car (this time in auto) and simply call the entire problem solved. Even with those problems, your car should still be worth five or six thousand as it sits.
[info]dixiemouse wrote:
Jun. 9th, 2008 09:08 pm (UTC)
I have to agree with some of the previous posts... find a good mechanic and go there... you can get the same warranties from a reputable mechanic (sometimes better, in fact...) as a dealership... I have also encountered less "Oh, look you're a girl, you can't possibly understand what I am saying." from mechanics than dealers...

Also, at 76K you might want to check the spark plugs and wires/cables (it you didn't have it done at 50K)... transmission fluid filter and change the fluid... and regular stuffs like peeking at brakes and clutch... boots, etc... if you were hree I could refer you to a MAGNIFICENT mechanic, but that's a little more inconvenient than Hayward ;)
[info]smmfryguy wrote:
Jun. 9th, 2008 11:36 pm (UTC)
This is off topic but you're someone whose opinion I respect so I figured I'd share.

I just agreed to a job offer to be an Associate Editor for Online News at Minnesota Public Radio in St. Paul, MN. It's pretty much my dream job. I'll be editing news stories for online, shooting and editing video and photos as well as other online duties. I might even get the chance to have my own podcast on the site.

My first big assignment will be helping them cover the Republican National Convention, in particular the 10,000+ protesters that are expected to roll into town.

So, now you know someone in the Twin Cities. Come visit!
[info]savorie wrote:
Jun. 10th, 2008 12:02 am (UTC)
I will! Major congrats!!! When do you move?

(Also-- *deeply flattered*)
[info]jhogan wrote:
Jun. 9th, 2008 11:56 pm (UTC)
Use Yelp. Find a good local mechanic that's trustworthy. Such a mechanic will probably tell you about the occasional times you're better off going to a dealer.
[info]savorie wrote:
Jun. 10th, 2008 12:03 am (UTC)
I did peruse Yelp about an hour ago and noticed stellar reviews for an auto shop LESS than a block from my house. Think I'll give them a try!
[info]jhogan wrote:
Jun. 10th, 2008 12:05 am (UTC)
Yay Yelp! Some old co-workers of mine started that. Such a phenomenally useful site. I thought for sure it was worthless when they launched it.
[info]savorie wrote:
Jun. 10th, 2008 12:31 am (UTC)
I'm inordinately fond of Yelp, and I would love to shake your old co-workers' hands. Like you, though, I initially didn't think it would catch on.